News 
 Opinion 
 Letters to the Editor 
 General 
 Letters to the editor 

Letters to the editor

09 Feb, 2010 08:07 AM
Omission

As much as I appreciate my letters being published, and realise some have to be edited, an omission or insertion of a word can change the meaning.

I refer to Responding to Roger (29/1).

I wrote, “I too believe there is God”, not “I believe there is a God”.

As this would suggest I believe in a Supreme Being, which I do not.

Dona Eaton

Lochiel

All stuffed

After Serena William’s win at the Australian Open, she was given a stuffed koala to cuddle as she acknowledged the cheers from the crowd and posed for photos.

If Forests NSW has its way and begins logging next month in the last koala colony in the Far South Coast of NSW, stuffed koalas will be the only kind that anyone will see in this area.

Lois Katz

Tathra

Congratulat ions

The members of the Bermagui Seaside Fair Committee extend their congratulations to Carl and Motria von Schreiber for becoming Australian citizens on January 26.

Chairperson for Seasiders, Jo Jacobs, said “Carl and Motria (and their veterinary clinic staff) have been assisting the Seaside Fair like true Aussies over many years to help make our annual event become what it is today.

“They have once again offered their services for the 13th Fair to be held on March 13, and will once again be co-ordinating the very popular Pet Pageant.

“So when you are bringing along your pampered pets to be judged at the Fair, say “Good On Ya” to our newest Aussies.”

Lori Hammerton

Bermagui Seaside Fair Committee

Impressed

We are 20 years residents/ratepayers of Bermagui.

We are greatly impressed with the new Julie Rutherford Building on the waterfront.

It’s a shame it was not named Fisherman’s Wharf or something similar.

Malcolm and Di Edge

Bermagui

Global warming

Carbon dioxide and methane, the two most common gases involved in potential global warming have been part of our atmosphere for millions of years, but other such as chlorofluorocarbons are recent by-products of industry.

About half the world’s population gets their daily energy needs from the burning of wood.

Wood is a renewable energy source but we are burning it faster than it can grow back.

One of the problems that I have with any debate or discussion about global warming is that we, the general public have to rely on information supplied by the media: newspapers, television, and the Internet.

I know that these organisations are in the business of making money for their shareholders, however, in most reports about climate change we have photographs or film showing coal fired power stations and the billowing clouds of CO2 gases polluting the atmosphere.

The problem is that these billowing clouds in most cases are nothing but hot air, steam, H2O, from water-cooling towers.

If the media are unable to distinguish between a chimneystack and a water-cooling tower, then the public is being provided with false and misleading information and consequently is being prohibited from making a valued assessment of the true facts about global warming.

Just ask these media organisations to print or show photographs of nuclear power stations and you will see the same water-cooling towers at these locations.

Estimates indicate that all known oil reserves could be 90 per cent depleted by 2040.

Coal reserves are much more plentiful, coal is a highly polluting fuel because it produces S02 when it burns.

These are two ways designed to reduce these emissions, desulphurization and coal gasification.

We have been told that with temperatures rising sea levels will increase, an increase in rainfall and flooding in some areas and drought in others, heat waves and wildfires, crop failures, contagious diseases and water wars.

I think that this message is getting through.

One of the problems we have with climate change sceptics is the recurring regurgitating of a hypothesis that has been disproved time and time again.

They behave like one-eyed supporters at a football game and bring nothing to solving a problem.

We have greasy wheels in South Australia clamouring for more water in Lake Alexandrina so that frogs can jump around and other wilderness radicals demanding the Snowy River have half a metre of water flowing under the Princes Highway at Orbost.

While all along the River Murray system, food processing factories and canneries have closed their doors.

Orchards, vineyards and wineries have been deprived of water and thousands of jobs lost.

And the land has no value without water rights.

The problem we face is not all about curtailing greenhouse emissions but also about eliminating those already in the atmosphere.

It’s all about atoms, molecules, and ions, thermodynamics and electrochemistry.

Ivor Williams

Brogo

Not science derived

I respond to the three correspondents (BDN 29/1) who responded to my letter published the Friday before.

Before responding in detail there is a phrase frequently bandied around in the climate change debate I wish to challenge which is “The science of climate change”.

I challenge this because climate change is not derived from science.

Science is a number of natural laws and principles which can be repeatedly demonstrated.

For instance gravity can be repeatedly demonstrated every time you drop something.

Climate change is based on a huge series of one-off observations which cannot be repeated therefore it is not science.

It is actually an exercise in statistics.

Now there is nothing wrong in this as we use statistics continually in our daily lives but science and statistics are two entirely different academic disciplines and should be recognised as such.

From science we derive facts which are truths which cannot be disputed but from statistics we derive opinions and there are as many opinions as there are people.

Opinions are believed or disbelieved.

If you believe one then you believe it by faith and this is the basis of all religion.

Therefore climate change and your attitude and approach to it is an article of your religion.

It is very interesting that my original letter and the letters of my three respondents have all approached climate change according to the respective faiths of the writers and not from science.

Rachel Colombo wrote me a poem about Gaia, the earth goddess, showing her approach is that of a New Age pantheist.

Dona Eaton seems to be a believer in environmental sustainability, while David Grainger denounces those who would have us worship at the environmental altar and make sacrifices to this new atheistic environmental religion.

He approaches the issue from a Christian viewpoint like myself.

One point I challenge is Dona Eaton’s reference to the apocalypse that is the total destruction of the earth at the end of time.

She seems to think we can avoid this.

We cannot.

The apocalypse is inevitable regardless of what we say or try to do.

There is good established science to say this will occur.

I refer to the Second Law of Thermodynamics or the Law of Entropy which has been established science now for 130 years, which says that all systems will eventually run down, fall apart and disintegrate.

We see this going on around us all the time but people have difficulty in accepting that this law applies to the entire universe which of course includes planet earth.

As I said in my first letter, climate change is a symptom of an ageing earth or in terms of the above law – entropy or the wearing out process.

It is inevitable and we cannot fix it.

We just have to learn to live with it.

I find it ironic that climate changers conveniently ignore this piece of real established science for I have never seen it factored into the so called “Science of Climate Change”.

The only ray of hope in all this is Jesus Christ who has promised those who love Him, forgiveness of their sin and a place with Him for eternity in the New Heavens and the New Earth He will create for those who love Him.

Roger Jones

Bemboka

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
I agreed with you Roger right up until your final paragraph.
Posted by Brian Smith, 14/02/2010 6:14:04 PM, on Bega District News

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.

Most popular articles

1) Apple iPhone 4 32GB44 plans 12%
2) Apple iPhone 4 16GB44 plans 6%
3) HTC Desire4 plans 2%
4) Apple iPhone 3GS 8GB33 plans 2%
5) Sony Ericsson Xperia X10 Mini Pro37 plans 1%

Mobile Phones | Broadband Plans

Get the best deal at Fairfax Digital - Rural Press



Bega District News







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Navigate

Classifieds

More Ways to Read

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2010. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...